Market

Market
Showing posts with label unemployment. Show all posts
Showing posts with label unemployment. Show all posts

Thursday, June 20, 2013

IS UNEMPLOYMENT RAMPANT IN INDIA? PROBABLY NOT!

There is a wide spread perception among international agencies that the unemployment situation in India is serious and people are starving because of lack of adequate income generation opportunities, especially for the vast mass of unskilled and illiterate citizenry. A recent report from the government sources however gives a totally different picture vis-a-vis the employment situation where people are shunning work even under some of the government sponsored employment schemes under some of the laws like Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act! If the employment situation is really grim, why should people shun the offer of the government to give work for every citizen above 18 years of age at least for 100 days in an year and in a family with at least two adults the annual income works out to more than Rs 30000, adequate for sustenance. Still demand for this dole out is progressively coming down during the last 4 years with very few takers coming forward to take up work under the Scheme! Why? What is the real reason? There may be many "official" explanations but the fact still remains that people do not want to take up this offer from the government because they have better income generating opportunities elsewhere! How can any one believe the 'statistics" being published regularly by the government on the unemployment situation in the country? Here is a take on this ironic situation. 

The Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act makes it mandatory for the State government to ensure a minimum 100 days of unskilled manual labour for any person above the age of 18, demanding employment under the scheme. But, cut to 2013, there are no takers for the scheme. As per the data provided by MGNREGA at the State level, between 2009-2010 and 2012-2013, the cumulative number of households with job cards demanding employment through this flagship scheme declined from 74,753 to 15,303 in Bangalore (both rural and urban). According to officials, in 2013-2014, there will be a further dip in the job demand. The total number of job cards issued to households in the City has also seen a sudden dip of 60 per cent in the past four years. The phenomenon is no different in other parts of Karnataka. In the same time period, the State has experienced a decline of around 61 per cent, from 36 lakh to 14 lakh, in job demand. "The scheme in Karnataka was started with great enthusiasm and had received good response from the people. But, in the last few years, the impact has tapered off to a great extent, due to several bureaucratic issues," said Chandrashekar, Joint Director, MGNREGS, Karnataka.

Another less charitable view of the situation is that people are being made lazy by various populist schemes through which government spends public money largely to further the interests of the political group that rules the country and they are satisfied by what they are getting almost free like rice, wheat, gas connections, television sets etc without raising a finger! With the Cash Transfer Scheme now being implemented at a huge cost, cash is going to be put in the hands of the so called poor to spend as they like and why should any one work if his needs are satisfied by sitting at home enjoying a retired life even before the life starts? Many critics believe that in a matter of few years after implementing all these misconceived schemes, India may have to import "human beings" from neighboring countries to do hard work on various developmental projects!. No wonder that industrial production is dipping alarmingly low and infrastructure activities are not taking off because of such a huge human shortage for doing hard work. What will be the impact of these changes on food production in future? Small farmers are likely to be wiped out leaving large landholders to carry out agricultural operations using large scale mechanization! Is India going to be a nation of zombies with no initiative to work and wasting precious human wealth? Only time will tell!   

V.H.POTTY
http://vhpotty.blogspot.com/
http://foodtechupdates.blogspot.com

Sunday, August 14, 2011

FDI IN INDIAN RETAIL SECTOR-IMPENDING POLICY CHANGE

Listening to some of the political comments which were orchestrated after the proposal to allow FDI in Indian retail system remind one of similar kind of sound bytes heard during the early decades of independence on the issue of encouraging large industries vis-a-vis the SMEs. To day whether one likes it or not large industrial monopolies have established themselves firmly in the business landscape of the country. Have the SMEs disappeared because of this development? A realty check will reveal that both large industries and small ones are co-existing without much of catharses. What has happened is that consumers are benefited immensely by the vast expansion of the product basket and dramatic improvement of product quality. Organized sector of food business whether in fruit processing or bakery sector, has not been able to even capture 50% of the market! Probably there is a synergistic development where product promotion by the big players gives sufficient space for smaller players to carve out a significant share, the latter's advantage being lower consumer price for their products. Similarly it is doubtful whether small retailer will ever disappear from the Indian landscape because of establishment hi-tech, glittering and air conditioned supermarkets operated by transnational companies. It is interesting to watch the performance of political parties on this issue.

"Along with price rise, unemployment has been increasing in this country. 50 per cent of our population, comprising of small traders, street-vendors and the self-employed sustain themselves through retail businesses. The UPA government wants to deprive them of livelihood by allowing FDI in multi-brand retail," BJP spokesperson Shahnawaz Hussain said. BJP will oppose this policy through which the government proposes to allow 100 per cent FDI in multi-brand retail in cities having population above 10 Lakh. The party has always counted on the support of small traders and feels that neighbourhood store-owners would be adversely affected by the entry of foreign brands like Walmart, Tesco and Carrefour. "The government should try to build a political consensus on this issue. The Rajya Sabha Standing Committee report had stated that FDI should not be allowed in retail as small shopkeepers would be affected," Mr. Hussain said. He alluded to this step being taken under foreign pressure, and mentioned the recent visit of US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton to India in this regard. "There is a suspicion that this government is working under pressure. Whenever some big leader, especially from the U.S., visits India the government forms a bigger committee to over-rule the decision of its Standing Committees," he said. A Committee of Secretaries, headed by Cabinet Secretary Ajit Seth, has cleared the proposal to have FDI in retail.

The experience so far indicates that organized retail has not made any dent so far in spite of the vast investments made by organized retailing giants within the country. According to estimates the retail business in the organized sector is hardly 4-5% and if FDI is allowed in this sector the scenario is not going to change much. The so called unorganized retailers are not going to stay quiet as being seen these days when many of them have modernized their outlets with scientific stock management and reduced loose vending. Added to this it is not realized that no transnational retailing organization will venture into rural areas with indifferent infrastructure, limited income, rampant illiteracy and it is here more than 70% of the country's population eke out a living. Besides Indian traders are no easy push over with their uncanny knack for business opportunities and they will remain a force o reckon with even under the worst scenario.