Market

Market
Showing posts with label FCI. Show all posts
Showing posts with label FCI. Show all posts

Thursday, January 22, 2015

Food subsidies in India-New suggestions to make them more rationale

The so called Food Security Act is an anachronism as it was based on a populist policy with the sole aim of collecting votes during election time from an electorate thought to be obliged to the political party that piloted the bill. The then government forgot that it was pledging future earnings of the country in perpetuating this dole out year after year working out to more than 1 lakh crore rupees an year! Revisiting this Act by the new government raised some hope that the senseless commitment of future generations to sustain the program might turn out to be a millstone around the neck of the nation. The Shantakumat committee set up to review the Act has submitted its recommendations recently wasting minimum time as is usually the case with government set up commissions. A perusal of the report gives hope that there would be drastic revision of the Act soon if government is serious about its intentions. A gist of the report is reproduced below which gives an insight into the thoughts of the experts who did a commendable job in record time. 

The government should reduce coverage under the National Food Security Act (NFSA) to 40% of the population from 67% and defer implementation of the scheme in states which have not complied with the rollout conditions, a panel appointed by Prime Minister Narendra Modi has recommended. The panel headed by former food minister Shanta Kumar submitted the report to the PM on Wednesday. Reforming the subsidy regime is a key plan of Modi's economic reforms. It has recommended far reaching changes in the functioning of the state-run Food Corporation of India (FCI) and the minimum support price (MSP) regime. It has suggested that the food grain under NFSA for those under the below poverty line should be raised to 7kg per person from the current norm of 5 kg. It has also called for moving to a direct cast transfer regime for food subsidy and estimates that the savings on food subsidy could be as much as Rs 30,000 crore per year. "Move to cash transfer and start with 53 million-plus cities. The states which are deficit in grains should be given the option of either grain or cash," said a source. The panel has also suggested that fertilizer subsidy should be paid to farmers directly on per hectare basis which comes to around Rs 7,000 per hectare. "This will result in saving nearly Rs 10,000 to Rs 15,000 crore annually in fertilizer subsidy," the source said. There should be a liquidation policy which will kick in immediately when the stocks go beyond the buffer stock limit. At present, FCI sells in open market or exports after approval cabinet which some experts say raises its carrying cost. "FCI should get a free hand," the source said. The panel has recommended that the name of FCI be changed. "The new of FCI will be akin to an Agency for Innovations in Food Management System with a primary focus to create competition in every segment of food grain supply chain, some procurement to stocking to movement and finally distribution in public distribution system so that the overall costs of the system are substantially reduced, leakages plugged and it serves large no of consumers and farmers," the source said. The panel has said that FCI should move its procurement move to eastern states. "If any state is giving bonus, the payment for the extra procurement should be borne by that state and not FCI," the source said. It has also suggested that there should be an upper limit on taxes imposed by states for procurement. For example, Punjab has 14.5% tax while Gujarat has less than 2%. "The upper limit should be 4%," the source said. The FCI should revamp its grain handling and stocking operations, the committee has recommended. It should move to bulk handling and mechanize the operations to reduce its dependence on so called "labour gangs." Temporary storage should be done away with gradually with no grain stock remaining for more than three months. The agency should run "grain trains" for moving food grains. The stocking operations should be handed over to the Central Warehousing Corporation, state warehousing corporations. The private sector should also be encouraged to build silos. All existing silos of FCI should be revamped, the panel has recommended. The country needs 10 million tones capacity of storage."Government needs to revisit its MSP policy. Currently, MSPs are announced for 23 commodities, but effectively price support operates primarily in what and rice and that too in selected states," the source said.

Suggestions like reducing the coverage to include only deserving population, reforming Food Corporation of India, reducing taxes on grains, moving to cash transfer mode for delivery, increasing the quantum receivable by a person by 40%, revising the norms for distribution of fertilizer subsidy to farmers, changing the minimum support price system etc will have far reaching benefits if implemented sincerely. There is one area where the Panel did not seem to have bestowed its attention and that pertains to integrating food security with nutrition security. Instead of a cereal only policy under NFSA, probably pulses at least could have been included in the benefit basket. The Andhra Pradesh model implemented recently under a new scheme provides 9 commodities including pulses, oil, salt etc though the coverage is comparatively small targeting certain poor segments of the population. Probably as a socially responsible country India must aim to improve the nutritional status of the poor people through supply of such a balanced food basket. 

V.H.POTTY
http://vhpotty.blogspot.com
http://foodtechupdates.blogspot.com

Tuesday, September 16, 2014

FOOD GRAIN WASTAGE AND THE SUPREME COURT-WILL THERE BE ACTION BY NDA GOVERNMENT?

True, a new government has taken over the reins in the country raising hopes of millions of Indians that better days are ahead in contrast to the policy paralysis prevalent earlier. But whether their hopes will fructify remains to be seen as bureaucrats still rule the roost and moving them to implement top policy decisions is still a big task. Food Corporation of India is a classical example about the bureaucratic grid lock that characterizes government programs, many of them well intended but not implemented properly. Looking back FCI and GOI were damned by the Supreme Court of India some time back for wasting precious food grains because of negligence and callousness in creating sound storage structures required to safe guard food grains for long duration. Here is a flash back on this issue and it is pitiable that nothing much has changed as far as this problem of wastage is concerned.  

"The court commissioners dubbed negligence by officials as `genocidal' and recommended responsibility and accountability be fixed at the highest level in Central and state governments. The commissioners have warned that this is just a third of the 1.37 lakh MT of wheat lying in the open since 2008-09 in Punjab, and the entire lot could have become unfit for consumption as Food Corporation of India (FCI) norms allow grains to be exposed to nature for only a year. In Haryana, too, 31,574 MT of grains have been lying in the open since 2008-09. Another 27.38 lakh MT of grain are lying in Punjab. While 18.90 MT of grains are wrapped in polythene, and gathering dust for the past two years. The commissioners report that "a significant quantity of these food grains are likely to go waste if urgent measures are not taken by the Government of India to release these stocks to poor immediately." The Supreme Court commissioners' statement comes in stark contrast to that of Pawar, who had earlier said in Parliament only 11,700 MT of grains worth Rs 6.86 crore had become unfit for consumption and reports of rotting grains were blown out of proportion. When contacted principle adviser to court commissioners, Biraj Patnaik, refused to comment, stating the issue is sub-judice. A counter affidavit filed by the government to this report quietly skirts the issue of rotting grains completely. Instead it talks of long-term arrangements to increase space for storage. The apex court, in its earlier hearing, had asked why grains should not be distributed to the poor instead of being allowed to rot in the open. The government claimed it cannot increase allocation of grains to the state under the PDS as it is not able take ad-hoc decisions while the new criteria is being developed by the government."

One of the redeeming pictures emerging now with the new government setting new standards of governance, FCI stored food grains are released into the open market in a controlled way which has resulted in reduction of prices in the case of some food grains, especially rice and wheat. Nothing much has been heard about the extent of rotten grains still with the FCI though the Court wanted this to be distributed to the poor. What is not realized is that these grains in all likelihood might be inedible even for animals because of severe infestation and contamination. It is time that government takes a serious view regarding this issue, sets in motion a review of acquirement policy and make the FCI accountable to the Nation. Recent direction to states not to increase Minimum Support price being offered to mop up surplus grains from the farmers may be a good move to divert these grains into open market and avoid long term storage for which adequate storage capacity is still not available. Also interesting is the announcement by the new government to restructure and recast the FCI to make them more efficient and accountable, though it remains to be seen whether such statements get translated into reality.  

V.H.POTTY
http://vhpotty.blogspot.com/
http://foodtechupdates.blogspot.com

Sunday, May 12, 2013

THE GRAIN OF "TRUTH"!-NATION'S FOOD "WOES" AND POLITICAL APATHY!

Indian nation has to thank the Supreme Court of the land for rapping at the knuckles of the political masters who claim they are "governing" the country, for the awfully sorry situation vis-a-vis food grain storage and mindless food wastage. It is a reflection of the total apathy of the political class, irrespective of their class or color or creed, that adequate precautions were not taken to save the food grains so painfully produced by the teeming millions of farmers through their sweat and blood by not expanding the storage capacity in commensurate with ever increasing production. Probably no where in the world except India one can witness the colossal loss of food year after after year through sheer negligence and callousness of unbelievable magnitude. In the latest report, the Comptroller and Auditor General of India (CAG) has made a scathing indictment of the government of the day for its continued neglect of food grains and granaries of the country.

'The national auditor highlighted the increasingly inadequate storage capacity of the Food Corporation of India (FCI), the government agency entrusted with food management and the procurement of food grains. This storage gap and other policies of the FCI led to food spoiling in a nation where millions still go hungry everyday. The Comptroller and Auditor General of India (CAG) said in its report that was tabled in Parliament on Tuesday that the storage gap widened to 331.85 lakh metric tonnes (LMT) from 59.95 LMT in the six-year period between 2007 and 2012. The report said efforts to address the issue were inadequate. "The storage gap in FCI against the central pool stock witnessed a steady increase during the period 2006-07 to 2011-12," it said. "Against the storage gap of 332 LMT (March 2012), GoI (government of India)/FCI envisaged capacity addition of only 163 LMT during the six-year period under various augmentation programmes. Of this, only 34 LMT was completed (March 2012)." Even as storage capacity remained inadequate, existing capacity was not completely utilized. The auditor observed that utilization of existing storage capacity in various states and union territories was less than 75% in the majority of the months between 2006-07 and 2011-12. This amounted to unnecessary expenditure of Rs.376 crore during the period as FCI didn't use the space it had in Punjab and Haryana, the auditor said. Though there was a steady increase in the food stock procured by government agencies, it didn't match allocation requirements under various government schemes. "The average food grains procurement of 514 LMT during the period 2006-07 to 2011-12 was lower than the average allocation of 593 LMT made by the government to states under the targeted public distribution system (TPDS) and other welfare schemes (OWS)," the report said. CAG highlighted the absence of specifications for maximum and manageable stock levels to be maintained in the central pool and of minimum buffer norms. It added that the existing buffer stock policy does not indicate which agency is primarily responsible for maintaining the minimum buffer stock level for the country as a whole, which adversely affects accountability and transparency in the management of food grains. The report said the government doesn't follow a specific policy for fixing the minimum support price (MSP) relative to the cost of production. "It was observed that the margin of MSP fixed over the cost of production varied between 29% and 66% in case of wheat, and 14% and 60% in case of paddy during the period 2006-07 to 2011-12. Increase in MSP had a direct bearing on statutory changes levied on purchase of food grains by different state governments," said the report, adding that this eventually resulted in the rising acquisition cost of food grains".

There will be blame game and "passing on the buck" statements regarding the reasons for this sordid affair but fact still remains that those culpable for this criminal negligence are never brought to books for their shirking of responsibility. Government "spin doctors" adept at interpreting any indictment as unavoidable, will continue to present a picture as not so discouraging, though more than 200 million people in this country are supposed to be going to bed every day on a hungry stomach! Even to day a non-repentant ruling regime does not seem to be serious about the plans to expand storage capacity and in stead trotting out tall claims about future plans to remedy the situation without really meaning a single word of what they are saying! This raises the logical question as to when this country is going to be ever salvaged from the self seeking politicians parading under the garb of democracy!  

V.H.POTTY
http://vhpotty.blogspot.com/
http://foodtechupdates.blogspot.com

Monday, December 3, 2012

INDIA TO BECOME A GLOBAL FOOD GRAIN TRADER?-THE RISK FACTOR

Food security for a country implies that adequate food is available to every citizen and there is no short supply. Unfortunately in India this term is being touted to imply that government warehouses hold adequate stocks of food grains, that too rice and wheat to meet the statistical average need of a person. The wide income disparity and extensive property do not allow such citizens to buy their food requirements is gloated over under the excuse that these segment of the population is covered by the inefficient and corrupt Public Distribution System or PDS under which Below Poverty Line families are supposed to get their minimum needs at very low cost. In this scheme Food Corporation of India {FCI) which is the nation's store keeper under GOI is supposed to manage grain procurement from farmers, store them safely and supply the same to so called ration shops spread all over the country. According to many studies it has become clear that more than 50% of the grains do not reach the targeted beneficiary, getting "leaked" on the way! FCI is also used as an arm for export and import of food grains as when there is a contingency. This very same agency is now being asked to get into global grain trading business assuming that such activities can reduce the subsidy burden of GOI. How far this may work out and the long term implications on country's domestic market are discussed in a recent report by an experienced expert on agricultural policies. here is a gist of it.  

"At a time when the Global Hunger Index 2012 ranks India 65th among 79 countries, K V Thomas, minister of state for food and public distribution and consumer affairs, has revealed that the Food Corporation of India (FCI) will soon trade wheat in the futures market. Seeking clearance from the Forward Markets Commission, the minister said: "The market has to perform the economic function of price discovery and price risk management." Well, what I can see as the basic objective is to replace the open market sales scheme with trading in the futures market. In other words, futures trading will provide an opportunity for FCI to make some profits, which in turn can be ploughed back in its procurement operations, thereby reducing the subsidy outgo".

A moot question that begs for an answer is whether India can really sustain itself as a viable food grain business player when the government is trying to usher in a new policy of supplying food grains at ridiculously low price covering almost 70% of the population? The requirement for such populist scheme is going to be huge and FCI is going to be tied to this challenge in the coming years. GOI does not seem to have learned its bad experience in propping up State Trading Corporation (STC) as a state controlled business arm by giving it monopoly in dealing with some portfolio and if FCI is now going to follow the footsteps of STC, one can imagine what would be the result. Unless the management structure and working style of FCI are drastically improved, the new policy may end up in another fiasco. This is not to under estimate the potential for FCI to become a global player in grain business as it is one of the world's largest grain dealers, handling massive quantities of food grains, primarily for domestic market and if this is to be realized GOI will have to relax its iron like grip on the functioning of the organization, giving it a free hand in day to day operations. Will this ever happen? No way, knowing the unlimited power wielded by bureaucracy on every institution in the country to day.

V.H.POTTY
http://vhpotty.blogspot.com/
http://foodtechupdates.blogspot.com
   

Thursday, May 17, 2012

INDIAN AGRICULTURE-HERE IS ANOTHER REPORT!

In the "Babu parlor" at Delhi, producing a glossy report is considered the ultimate in assessing the work of any government department or Planning Commission. Whether the claims, promises and projection are achievable or actually achieved within the time frame does not appear to be bothering any one because there are lot of stock "excuses" readily available to explain away non-performance! If all the Babu Reports during the last 50 years emanating from the stables of government departments are collected it may require enormous storage space greater than that presently available with FCI for grain storage! Here is another high sounding report from Delhi which is supposed to highlight the future strategy of the government on agriculture, food, health and other issues concerning the country. Unfortunately it does not make any sense to the common man, steeped in pessimism looking at the track record of performance of the government. Here is a take on this "interesting" report with very little substance but high on platitudes and verbosity. 

"As per the report, the thrust areas for the agriculture sector include enhancing public sector investment in research and effective transfer of technology along with institutional reforms in research set up to make it more accountable and geared towards delivery, conservation of land, water and biological resources, development of rainfed agriculture, development of minor irrigation, timely and adequate availability of inputs, support for marketing infrastructure, increasing flow of credit particularly to the small and marginal farmers. The report highlights the fall in contribution of agriculture to the overall Gross Domestic Product (GDP), which has gone down to 13.9% (from 18% two years ago). It notes that this trend is expected in the development process of any economy. Yet, agriculture forms the backbone of development, as 52% of India's work force is still engaged in agriculture for its livelihood and is important for food security and inclusive growth. The report highlights the records achieved in the production of food grains and many other crops. Among the major steps taken in the recent years for improving crop production and productivity, the report specially highlights the contribution made by the Rashtriya Krishi Vikas Yojana (RKVY) towards increasing public investment in agriculture and allied sectors. National Food Security Mission (NFSM) and the National Horticulture Mission (NHM) have also emerged as the path breaking interventions which have helped in achieving record production of cereals, pulses, oil seeds, fruits, vegetables and spices during the last two years. Bringing Green Revolution in Eastern India (BGREI) has been started to increase the productivity of the cropping system mainly rice, wheat, maize, pulses through promotion of innovative production technologies and agronomical practices addressing the underlying key constraints of different agro-climatic sub regions. The 'State of Indian Agriculture' report emphasises the need to bridge the yield gap in low productivity regions by technology, inputs and other interventions. Raising productivity also assumes significance in view of increasing demand for land for industrialization, urbanization, housing and infrastructure. The report takes note of the structural changes in the composition of Indian agriculture, leading to diversification into horticulture, livestock and fisheries since the 1990s. Analysing the likely high contribution of these high-value sectors, the report says that the shares of fruits & vegetables and livestock have shown an increasing trend in recent years and have been growing at much faster rates than the traditional crops sector. Given the rising share of high value commodities in the total value of agricultural output and their growth potential, this segment is expected to drive agricultural growth in the years to come. Bringing in reforms to streamline domestic markets and expanding the infrastructure and institutions to connect local markets with national and global markets, will go a long way in improving India's competitiveness and the benefits from trade liberalization. Higher investment in basic infrastructure like roads, canal waters, watersheds, check dams, etc. will attract private investment in other areas of the supply chain. Highlighting the importance of private sector investment, the report observes that the private sector responds much better and faster to the incentive structures. Hence, along with bringing in greater public investment in agriculture, there is a need for bringing in reforms in the incentive structure in agriculture".

What the common man is interested is in feeling the result of development at the ground level and unfortunately there is nothing much to show except these voluminous reports. The farmer suicides continue unabated, poverty progresses without any let up, health deterioration of the population is alarming, PDS is hijacked to line the pockets of mafias, land is being grabbed all over the country and scams have become the center of governance! It is not suggested that there is a magic wand that can find solution to the problems country is facing but to have no sensitivity to the sufferings of the citizen is unpardonable. In every walk of life the citizen is being "beaten" hollow by tyrannical policies of administration, whether local, regional, state or central government. Indians are second to none in making sacrifices as long they are shared equally by all but allowing only a few privileged and well connected people cornering all the fruits of development is nothing but criminal!

V.H.POTTY
http://vhpotty.blogspot.com/
http://foodtechupdates.blogspot.com
     

Wednesday, December 21, 2011

THE BUFFER STOCK MUDDLE-IS THERE NO ACCOUNTABILITY IN INDIA?

Critics of Indian government policies and its style of governing are often tarred with a brush accusing them of vested interest and branded as politically motivated! Latest case is the reported mismanagement of buffer stock management which, in turn is closely related to country's food security, does not seem to have any priorities and characterized by lethargic response during periods of food crisis. Interestingly this accusation has come not from trenchant critics but from a Parliamentary committee on public undertakings and one should not forget that this has happened despite the UPA being the ruling combine that controls the government! It looks like food security is simply a populist slogan for politicians in the country without any serious intention to work seriously on achieving the same. Look at the priority of GOI to day when it is thinking only in terms of increasing subsidies from the exchequer for distribution of food grains at prices which are ridiculously low to population supposed to be "poor" though the Public Distribution System already existing has become so rotten even GOI does not know where bulk of the food ends up! Is this not an action for strengthening the "loot brigade" that operates in the country for siphoning off the PDS food grains before it reaches the beneficiaries?. If there is at at least a modicum of accountability those who have been looting the country should have been hanged long ago. Reports like this do not shame the perpetrators of such heinous crimes as ill gotten money is a great "eraser" of all sins!    

A Parliamentary committee has directed the government to ensure the finalisation of the buffer stocking policy for foodgrains within three months. While presenting its report today, the Committee on Public Undertakings headed by Jagdambika Pal expressed "grave concern" over the slow pace of action by the government on the handling of buffer stock policy for food grains. "Expressing their grave concern over the slow pace of action in a matter of serious national issue involving the food security of the country, the committee exhort the department (Food) to address this issue in right earnest and ensure finalisation of buffer stocking policy within 3 months of the presentation of this report," it pointed out. The panel in its earlier report presented to Lok Sabha in February 2009 had recommended that the Food Ministry should go in for intensive technological upgrades to review the buffer stock norms for food grains. It had also suggested that the ministry can take help from Economic Survey, Planning Commission, Finance Ministry, Agriculture Ministry, etc while fixing buffer stock norms. The Department of Food and Public Distribution (F & PD) in its action taken replies furnished in March 2010 had said that the Technical Group headed by F & PD Secretary had asked the National Centre for Agricultural Economics (NCAP) to review the existing buffer stock policy, it added. "The committee are, however, astonished at the subsequent action taken reply furnished by the department in January 2011 that while NCAP report on the subject matter had been considered by the technical group on buffer stocking policy, its report is yet to be finalised," the panel pointed out. The committee felt that the matter has not been given the serious attention that it deserved. The issue relates to the position of food grain stocks with the government in October 2003 and based upon which the Committee on Public Undertakings in its report in 2009 had advised the government to upgrade its buffer stock norms. The panel in its previous report in February 2009 had found the handling of buffer stock of food grains by the Food Corporation of India (FCI) as a case of mismanagement. The committee in its report then had observed that the government committed an error of judgement while handling food grain stocks during 2002-03 and 2003-04. The country had a food grains stock position of 152 lakh tonnes as on October 1, 2002 against the norm of 65 lakh tonnes, but on October 1, 2003, the stock of food grains stood at 52 lakh tonnes against the norm of 65 lakh tonnes, it said. "The committee feel that the government itself has to be blamed for the situation when it allowed high stocks to be piled up and then liquidating the same through exports leading to shortage," it had said. 

The latest extravaganza being unleashed by GOI is coming in the form of Food Security Bill which is likely to become a law soon if the present ruling group has its say and 75% of Indian citizens need not work hard any more because each person can get 7 kg of food grains per month for just Rs 7 while the market price is ruling around Rs 200 for the same quantity! With the poverty level of income being fixed at Rs 32 per day (under MGNREGA scheme Rs 100), one can understand poorest of the poor getting such help from GOI but it is beyond comprehension as to why food should be distributed at such a low cost to others. If this is not electoral calculation what else has motivated the GOI to go for such blatantly populist scheme under the banner of "right to food"? With Food Corporation of India in such a mess, as pointed out by the Parliamentary Committee, it defies logic and common sense as to how this mega "give away" scheme is going to be managed and what economic burden the country will have to bear for this ill considered move?

V.H.POTTY
http://vhpotty.blogspot.com/
http://foodtechupdates.blogspot.com
                                                         

Saturday, November 12, 2011

"PASSING THE BUCK"-FCI SHIRKING ITS RESPONSIBILITY?

"Passing the buck" is a favorite game among the bureaucrats who want to shirk their responsibility. It is a rare instance when a bureaucrat is taken to task for not performing the assigned duties. In India bribe taker is invariably not punished while the bribe givers are relentlessly pursued for appropriate action! Here is an instance of India's grain handling monolith coming put with a policy to do away with quality inspection assessment practices and asking the state governments to do that function under the so called decentralization policy, the excuse being shortage of personnel. How can an organization like this, vested with ensuring food security in the country can do such a policy turn around is beyond the comprehension of many concerned citizens. Probably this strategy might have been chalked out to deflect serious criticism leveled against FCI for delivering sub standard grains to PDS beneficiaries and for allowing a portion of the grains procured to rot in the open from time to time. Since it is the prime responsibility of FCI to ensure food quality and safety for which it has been provided with adequate funds and personnel, how can it say that it is short of personnel? It is unfortunate that FCI is playing a dangerous game taking risk with the lives of millions of PDS beneficiaries through this rash action. Will the GOI support such a policy? One can only watch the situation with some alarm. 

"Reeling under staff shortage, the Food Corporation of India (FCI) has declined to carry out quality control inspection of foodgrains procured by State agencies and stored in their stockyards. In a letter, the General Manager of FCI has conveyed the status to the Food Supplies and Consumer Welfare Department which, in turn, has asked all Collectors and Civil Supplies Officers to ensure that quality is maintained from FCI depots to distribution points. The Centre had, in August, directed states to ensure procurement of stocks as per the prescribed quality standards and maintain the same in the storage, till it is taken over by FCI. In fact, under the decentralised procurement (DCP) scheme, procurement of food grains and safe maintenance during storage till distribution is the responsibility of the State Government. Similarly, the Government has to ensure quality of food grains received from depots of FCI till the stock is distributed among the beneficiaries through fair price shops.� The primary responsibility of maintaining quality of food grains will be the concern of the State. Amidst all this, FCI is facing serious shortage of quality control personnel. In the last nine years, the total� strength� of quality control staff has decreased from 5,111 to 4,001. In view of the shortage, FCI has conveyed that it may not undertake routine inspection of wheat and paddy procured by State agencies and stored in their godowns. However, inspection of wheat and rice delivered at FCI godowns will continue to be undertaken by the quality control staff of the corporation. In case of complaints received about poor quality of food grains procurement and maintenance of stocks by the State, FCI will inspect the stocks jointly with quality control staff of the State agencies and a joint report generated. The corporation has made it clear that it will be the responsibility of the Government to inspect quality of stocks issued by its agencies to respective fair price shops".

It looks like a "divide" is being created between states and the Center which may probably help for playing the "blame game" which will weaken the very foundation of the federal democratic structure of the country, the ultimate sufferer being the poor consumer, caught in the cross fire. If there is a shortage of personnel what prevented the FCI to recruit more to reach the optimum figure essential to carry out its tasks efficiently? None else but the FCI has to be blamed for both serious shortage of  storage facilities to protect the grains procured as well as its inability to "see beyond its nose" to set up necessary training infrastructure to turn out technical staff required for quality checking and other related technical activities. It is time GOI revisits the objective of setting up FCI and the way it is working now! Why not convert FCI into a corporate entity like some of the giant grain companies like Archer Daniel Midlands (ADM) with sound economic rationale? While it should have sufficient infrastructure to procure, store and transport its grains, similar organizations at the state level can be purely distribution entities, buying and distributing the food grains to PDS out lets on behalf of GOI. Government subsidies can go directly to the state entities to buy and deliver the grains to targeted beneficiaries.

V.H.POTTY
http://vhpotty.blogspot.com/
http://foodtechupdates.blogspot.com